🎶 2022-08-31 20:55:00 - Paris/France.
Phakathi kwezinto ekujoliswe kuzo yayiyimvumi uMariah Carey, iAtlanta Falcons ebanzi eyamkela uCalvin Ridley kunye nomdlali wegoli waseAtlanta United uBrad Guzan, ngokwezityholo ezingama-220.
“Ndicinga ukuba ukuba uthatha isigqibo sokuvuma ulwaphulo-mthetho lwakho ngesingqi, ndiza kusisebenzisa,” watsho, ephembelela ukugxekwa. “Andijongi mntu, kodwa awukwazi ukwenza ubugebenga kwindawo endihlala kuyo uze uthathe isigqibo sokuqhayisa ngalo. »
Wongeze wathi: “Ndinengcebiso yezomthetho. Sukuvuma ulwaphulo-mthetho lwamazwi e-rap ukuba awufuni asetyenziswe. »
Abaqulunqi bomthetho basebenzela ukukhusela intetho
Ukulandela izimangalo zika-Young Thug kunye noGunna, uWillis uxelele iintatheli ukuba uyakholelwa kwisiHlomelo sokuQala, kodwa akukho nto kwisilungiso esithintela abatshutshisi ekusebenziseni amazwi njengobungqina.
Unyanisile, kodwa kukho iqela elikhulu lamagcisa, amagqwetha, oonjingalwazi kunye nabezopolitiko abasebenza ukutshintsha loo nto.
“Kukho umsantsa kumthetho kwaye umsantsa uvumela ukuphathwa gadalala, kwaye sizamile ukuvala isithuba ngokutshintsha ngokusemthethweni imithetho kwilizwe lonke ukuze wonke umntu – oku kuthetha wonke umntu, kwaye ndithetha wonke umntu – abe nelungelo lokuxoxwa kwetyala ngobulungisa, ” yatsho igqwetha u-Alex Spiro, omele iirapper ezifana noJay-Z, uMeek Mill kunye no-21 Savage.
USpiro uthumele ileta kulo nyaka kwindlu yowiso-mthetho yaseNew York exhasa i-S7527, ebizwa ngokuba yibhili “yomculo we-rap ekulingweni”. Umthetho osayilwayo, owapasisa i-Senate ngoJuni kodwa usahamba ngenqanawa kwiNdlu yoWiso-mthetho, uya kunciphisa "ukwamkelwa kobungqina bokuyila kommangalelwa okanye intetho yobugcisa ngokuchasene nomtyholwa kumatyala olwaphulo-mthetho." Ekunye nabathengi bakhe abadumileyo, uSpiro wajoyinwa nguAndrea Dennis kunye no-Erik Nielson, ababhali be "Rap on Trial: Race, Lyrics and Wilt in America," abathi baphindaphinda ukuba bayazi ngamakhulu amatyala apho amazwi e-rap aye axhotyiswa ngabamangalelwa, kwaye bakrokrela ukuba uninzi alukhange lufumane ingqwalasela yoluntu. Abenzi bomthetho baseCalifornia bapasise umthetho ofanayo kulo nyaka ofuna iinkundla "zithathele ingqalelo izinto ezithile xa zilinganisa ixabiso lobungqina obunjalo ngokuchasene nengozi enkulu yocalucalulo olungafanelekanga." Ulindele ukutyotyelwa kwerhuluneli. Kwinqanaba le-federal, u-Reps. U-Hank Johnson waseGeorgia kunye no-Jamaal Bowman waseNew York bazisa uMthetho wokubuyisela uBugcisa boBugcisa kwiNdlu yase-US ngoJulayi, oya kunciphisa "ukuvunyelwa kobungqina bomsebenzi wokudala okanye ubugcisa bomculi". intetho echasene neli gcisa enkundleni. Umthetho oyilwayo awukafikeleli emgangathweni ukuze kuvotelwe. Kwingxelo yeendaba, uJohnson ucaphule ingxelo yejaji yomanyano ngo-2021 kwityala lerapper yasePhiladelphia: "UFreddy Mercury akazange avume 'ukubulala nje umntu' ngokubeka 'umpu ukuba udubule entloko yakhe' kunye "nokutsala i-trigger". UBob Marley akazange avume ukudubula isherifu, kwaye uJohnny Cash akazange avume ukudubula "indoda eReno, nje ukuyibukela isifa." “
“Ukwamkela imilinganiselo emibini kuyingozi”
USpiro ngaphambili wayeligqwetha lesithili saseManhattan kwaye wasebenza neyunithi eyayiphonononga izigwebo ezinokuba ziphosakele. Uwabonile amazwi eengoma eziziswe enkundleni amatyeli aliqela, kubandakanywa namatyala ebheyile apho abatshutshisi betyhola ummangalelwa ukuba ngumgulukudu ngenxa yamazwi akhe kunye nendlela athetha ngayo, "into edida ingqondo kwaye ayinangqondo," utshilo.
“Ndihlala ndinexhala kweli lizwe xa kukho ubungqina obufunekayo kwityala lolwaphulo-mthetho, kufuneka umntu azame ukusebenzisa amazwi omculo ukuqinisa elo nqanaba lobungqina – ingakumbi ngembali engcungcuthekiswayo kweli lizwe yokungabinabantu kweli lizwe. inkqubo iphathwe ngokufanayo nabanye, ”uxelele i-CNN.
Ebuzwa ukuba ingaba kubalulekile na kwishishini laseAtlanta ukuba uWillis wayemnyama, uSpiro wathi, "Hayi." Xa kamva ebuzwa ukuba ngaba uye wabona naziphi na iimeko apho amagcisa kuhlobo olumhlophe ngokwesiko njengelizwe okanye ilitye banamazwi angathandekiyo abhekiswe kubo, igqwetha laphendula lathi, “Ngokuqinisekileyo akunjalo.” »
U-Atlanta's Killer Mike, oye wathetha ngokuphandle ngalo mbandela, ukhuthaze abalandeli bakhe baka-Twitter ukuba bafunde incwadi kaDennis noNielson kule veki ngelixa ebonisa into ayibona njengemigangatho ephindwe kabini edlalwayo.UNancy Crampton-Brophy, isicengcelezo esiphawulweyo, wagwetywa ngokubulala umfazi, kodwa abatshutshisi kwafuneka baphumelele ityala ngaphandle kobungqina obuphambili emva kokuba ijaji yabanqanda ukuba bavume isincoko sakhe, "Indlela Yokubulala Umyeni Wakho," kuba wabhala iminyaka ngaphambili.
“Usagwetyiwe kodwa amalungelo akhe ebehlonitshiwe. Ukwamkela imigangatho ephindwe kabini kuyingozi, yiyo yonke into endiyithethayo, ”utshilo uKiller uMike kuTwitter.
U-Spiro naye uye wathatha inxaxheba kwisibongozo kwiNkundla ePhakamileyo yase-United States ukuba ibeke umgangatho kwityala lika-2019, u-Jamal Knox v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, kodwa inkundla ephakamileyo yalile ukuva eli tyala. La magqwetha ebenethemba lokuba iijaji ziza kulamkela eli tyala ukuze zijongane nento uSpiro ayibiza ngokuba “ngumsantsa emthethweni.”
U-Knox kunye nogxa wakhe uRashee Beasley batyholwa ngokugrogrisa ngokubulala amapolisa emva kokubanjwa neheroin kunye nompu. Nangona amatyala amaninzi abandakanya abatshutshisi abadibanisa amagcisa kulwaphulo-mthetho ngokucaphula amazwi kwi-abstract, u-Knox no-Beasley baye bakhethwa, babiza amagosa kunye nokuqhayisa ngokwazi iishedyuli zabo.
"Ndiza kuncamathelisa le mela enomhlwa emathunjini akhe kwaye ndinqumle iinyawo zakhe / Uthatha imali ka-Beaz kunye nayo yonke ikaka yam kum / Ewe, i-shift yakho ikwi-3 kwaye ndiza kudlala apho ulala khona", u-Knox unesingqisho. .
UBeasley wongeze ukuba "wayebotshwe kakubi" njengoRichard Poplawski, ebhekisa kwindoda eyayixhobe kakhulu eyabulala amapolisa amathathu ePittsburgh ngo-2009.
Omnye wamagosa wangqina ukuba uye wathatha umhlala phantsi emkhosini kwaye wahamba ngenxa yengoma, ngelixa elinye lalifuna ixesha lokuphumla kunye neenkcukacha zokhuseleko, wachaza.
U-Knox wagwetywa ngamatyala amabini ogrogriso lobunqolobi kunye namatyala amabini okugrogrisa amangqina, athe axhaswa ziinkundla zezibheno. INkundla ePhakamileyo yasePennsylvania yacaphula ukungafani kwee-rapper ekugwebeni ukuba le ngoma ibeka "isisongelo sokwenyani kumaxhoba" engafanelanga ukukhuselwa kwi-First Amendment.
Sisiphi isisongelo sokwenene?
Umsantsa kumthetho ubandakanya inkcazo esemthethweni yesoyikiso sokwenyani - umbuzo iingcali zithi iNkundla ePhakamileyo yase-US yashiya ivuliwe kwiminyaka emine ngaphambili kwityala layo lika-Elonis v. AMAZWE AMANYENE.
U-Anthony Elonis uthumele izoyikiso kumajelo eendaba ezentlalo, kwiskit nakumazwi e-rap ejolise kwabo babesakuba ngugxa wakhe, owayesakuba ngumfazi wakhe kunye nezikolo zamabanga aphantsi. Xa iiarhente ze-FBI zandwendwela ikhaya lakhe, waya kuFacebook ukuze athumele: “I-arhente encinci yema kufutshane kakhulu / ndathatha onke amandla endinawo ukuba ndingayijiki i-bitch yesiporho / rhola imela yam, ndibethe isandla sam kwaye ndiyinqumle umqala. wopha kwi jugular ukuya ezingalweni zeqabane lakhe. »
Phakathi kokukhulula amazwi, u-Elonis wabhekisela kwidabi lokuQala lokuLungiswa, esithi, "Ubugcisa bumalunga nokutyhala imida." Ndikulungele ukuya entolongweni ngenxa yamalungelo am omgaqo-siseko. Kwaye wena? »
U-Elonis wagwetywa ngamatyala amane okuphula umthetho we-federal kwaye wagwetywa iinyanga ezingama-44 entolongweni. Kodwa kwinkundla ephakamileyo, iqela lakhe lezomthetho laphikisa ukuba umbhalo wakhe wawuyi-cathartic, uthelekisa amazwi akhe nalawo kaEminem, owathi ngokuphindaphindiweyo wasongela ngokubulala umfazi wakhe nabanye kumculo wakhe. Ityala, ekukholeleka ukuba lelokuqala leNkundla ePhakamileyo ukujongana nezoyikiso zokwenyani kumajelo onxibelelwano, laphela ngesigwebo se-8-1 sokuba inkundla ephantsi yenze impazamo ekugwebeni u-Elonis ngokusekelwe kwibango lokuba umntu onengqiqo unokuthatha imiyalezo yakhe njengesoyikiso. .
Umgangatho onjalo wezomthetho wawuphantsi kakhulu, inkundla yagweba kunye noJaji oyiNtloko uJohn Roberts wabhala: "Isigqibo sethu sibonisa ngokucacileyo ukuba ukungakhathali akwanelanga ukukhupha isigwebo." »
Ukanti inkundla ephakamileyo yawushiya uvulekile ukuba umgangatho ufanele ukuba yintoni kwaye ayizange iwuphendule umbuzo obanzi womgaqo-siseko, abathi abahlalutyi baya kukhokelela kwizigqibo ezingafaniyo.
Umhlalutyi uLyle Denniston ubhalele i-SCOTUSblog ukuba isigqibo "sisekelwe kuphela kwisiseko sokuba (u-Elonis) ugwetyelwe ngaphandle kobungqina bokuba wayesazi ukuba wayebhala ntoni kwaye intsingiselo ecacileyo yamazwi akhe yayiya kuba yingozi." I-Federal Actual Threats Act ka-1939 ifuna ukuba unxibelelwano oluqulathe isoyikiso lusasazwe kwaye ummangalelwa azi. ukuchasa ngokuyinxenye.
U-Alito uxele kwangaphambili ukuba esi sigqibo siza “kubangela isiphithiphithi kunye neengxaki ezinzulu” kuba uninzi lunike impendulo engeyiyo kuphela kwimeko yengqondo efunekayo ukuze ugwetywe, utshilo uDenniston. UThomas wakhalaza ngelithi esi sigqibo sishiya iinkundla eziphantsi “ziqikelela imeko yengqondo efanelekileyo” efunekayo ukuze agwetywe. Uyikhabile indlela yenkundla yezibheno yangaphambili, eshiya "into engekho ndawo," wabhala uThomas.
Rappers: Ubugcisa bethu abunakuthelekiswa nanto
Uluntu lwe-hip-hop luyibona ngokulula ngakumbi, njengoko kungqinwa ngokufutshane okufakwe kwiminyaka emine kamva kwityala le-Knox nguSpiro kunye noChance the Rapper, Killer Mike, 21 Savage, Meek Mill, Fat Joe kunye noLuther Campbell, kuquka i-2 Live Iqela labasebenzi lidlale indima ebalulekileyo ekubumbeni imithetho yamanyala yesizwe ngeminyaka yoo-1990. “Iimvumi zeRapper zixhomekeke ekuzibaxeni nakwizibaxo ukudala abalinganiswa abakhulu kunobomi abasonwabisa abalandeli (kunye nabagxeki abakhubekisayo) kangangamashumi eminyaka,” isho le nto emfutshane. “Umntu ongaqhelananga nolona hlobo lomculo lwaziwayo ngoku okanye ova umculo ngeendlebe zeentlobo zakudala ezifana ne<em>jazz, i<em>country, okanye i-symphony usenokuyichaza ngendlela ephosakeleyo ingoma ye<em>rap njengesisongelo sokwenene sogonyamelo yaye usenokugqiba ngobuxoki. umculi we-rap wayenenjongo yokudlulisela isoyikiso sokwenene sobundlobongela xa engazange. »
Bachaza kwangaphambili ukuba ukugwetyelwa kukaKnox bekuya kubonisa ukuba imigangatho eyahlukeneyo isetyenziswa kumculo werap xa kuthelekiswa nezinye iindlela zokuzonwabisa. USpiro akayiboni ngokwahlukileyo namhlanje, yiyo loo nto esebenze neerapper, abezopolitiko kunye neetanki zokucinga "ukunika ilizwi kwiinzame ezahlukeneyo zezopolitiko," utshilo.
"Akukho mzekelo ubophelelayo othi awukwazi, akunjalo?" Kwaye ke xa umthetho ungatsho ukuba awukwazi ukwenza into kwaye ungumtshutshisi ozama ukufumana isigwebo, iingxaki zinokuvela, ”utshilo.
"Ngenxa yobunzima bengozi enokuthi ibangele kunye namalungelo abalulekileyo obugcisa kunye namalungelo oLungiso lokuQala asemngciphekweni, kungumnxeba olula," kusho ummeli. “Akufunekanga siyilibale imbali yeli lizwe kunye nento yokuba izinto ezinokuthi zisetyenziswe ukulinganisa abantu abathile abahluthwayo ... kwinkqubo yobulungisa kulwaphulo-mthetho kufuneka ijongwe ngokuthandabuza okukhulu – kwaye inye. “
U-Amy Simonson we-CNN, uDave Alsup kunye noLeah Asmelash baba negalelo kule ngxelo.
SOURCE: Uphonononga Iindaba
Ungalibazisi ukwabelana ngenqaku lethu kwiinethiwekhi zentlalo ukusinika ukomelela okuqinileyo. 🤗