😍 2022-11-04 17:55:00 - Paris/France.
Inguqulelo entsha ngaphambili. Ekuqaleni yabhalwa ngo-1929 nguErich Maria Remarque, Akukho ndaba ngaphambili wayenenguqulelo yefilimu engalibalekiyo ngo-1930. Waphumelela imifanekiso eqingqiweyo emibini ye-Oscar, eyona nto ibalulekileyo kulo msitho, uMfanekiso oBalaseleyo kunye noMlawuli oPhetheyo (i-Lewis Milestone). I-Les Remembered ngumboniso bhanyabhanya kamabonakude ka-1979 ngu-American Delbert Mann.
Phantse kwinkulungwane emva kokugqitywa kwayo, umalathisi waseJamani uEdward Berger (uloyiko) ibone kufanelekile ukugunyazisa uhlengahlengiso olutsha, ngeli xesha luthethwa ngolwimi lwangaphambili lwabalinganiswa abaphambili kunye nemboniso yokuqala ehambelana nokuvela kwakhona kwezilogeni ezichasene nemfazwe.
Embindini weprojekthi kwakukho iingcamango ezimbalwa eziphambili: kwakungekho bugorha okanye uzuko lokusindiswa kwimfazwe; Ukoyikeka kweMfazwe Enkulu kusenokuba kulityalwe ngenxa yeziganeko ezimbi kakhulu zeMfazwe Yehlabathi II, kunye nendlela yayo ekhohlakeleyo kwiziganeko zokwenyani, kwakubalulekile ukuba kubekho ubudlelwane obusondeleyo nabalinganiswa abaphambili, ukuqala ngoPaul Bäume (umlingisi waseOstriya uFelix Kammerer), oneminyaka eli-17 ubudala ongenela umkhosi waseJamani aze agqibele umphambili wasentshona.
"Kuzo zonke izigqibo zethu - ikhamera, umculo, uyilo lwemveliso, izambatho, iipropu okanye nantoni na - kwakubalulekile (ukubonakalisa) oko uPawulos, okanye nabani na okwisakhelo, uvakalelwa ngaloo mzuzu. Ngaloo ndlela, ndingathi mhlawumbi ngumfanekiso osondeleyo waba bantu batsha,” uBerger uxelele iDeadline.
Isimbuku sezi zigqibo sibonakale kwiintsuku ezimbalwa kwiNetflix, apho ifilim yefilimu iye yaba sesinye sezona zihloko zijongwe kakhulu kwiNetflix. Ukusasaza. Ukukhululwa okuphindaphinda indumiso awayesele eyifumene kwiminyhadala yamazwe ngamazwe nakwilizwe lakhe, elamkhetha njengomgqatswa wendawo ukuze akhuphisane ne-Oscar yefilimu engcono kakhulu yamazwe ngamazwe (udidi olufanayo apho iBlanquita yaseChile , kunye neArgentina, Ngo-1985, iBelgian Shutdown kunye neSigqibo saseMzantsi Korea sokuhamba).
“Konke ukuThula kwiMida ePhambili ngumsebenzi omkhulu kwaye onzima, owenziwe ngokungxamisekileyo kwaye ugxile kwaye unemiboniso yethafa ledabi eliwenziwe ngobuchule bedijithali kunye nesenzo. Ayinakuze isilele ukwenza okusesikweni komxholo wayo, nangona isazi imeko yayo yakudala, utshilo uThe Guardian, esongeza ukuba “yifilimu enamandla, eliciko nelokuzicingela ngokwalo.
Iyibiza ngokuba "yeyona nguqulelo iphefumlayo nenomtsalane" yencwadi, iChicago Sun-Times iphonononge: Njengoninzi lwemiboniso bhanyabhanya ebalaseleyo yemfazwe, ukusuka kwiiNdlela zoBuqaqawuli ukuya kwiPlatoon, Ukugcina iRyan yabucala kunye no-1917, ngamava anzima kwaye ngamanye amaxesha abuhlungu, kodwa ikwangummangaliso wobugcisa, isifundo somlinganiswa esenziwe ngononophelo. Isikhumbuzo esisexesheni sokuba abantu abaselula abalwa baze bancama, babulale baze bafele emfazweni bangamaxhaphetshu kumdlalo omkhulu, ontsokothileyo nosoloko uphambana ngokungeyomfuneko wechess.
Okuphakathi kancinci, i-portal ye-Indiewire yagcina ukuba "kukho ubunzima obuthile beTeutonic ekwenzeni ifilimu, kunye nakumxholo. Njengoko ikhazimlisiwe kodwa ingekho ngokukhazimlayo njengo-Sam Mendes ka-1917, ifilim ibonisa inqanaba elifanayo lokuzibophelela kwiinkcukacha zembali, kodwa inikezela ngemiboniso yayo yedabi ecwangcisiweyo ngesimbo esilula sokuthethwa. »
Kumbandela wemfazwe, le ndawo iphawula ukuba “ububudenge bayo nobubudenge buhlala buhleli, njengoko ubuso bayo buguquka ngokuhamba kwexesha. Ngelishwa, inguqulelo yebali ka-Edward Berger entle kodwa ekudala ilindelwe ayongezi nto ingako kwi-canon ngaphandle kwembonakalo entle kakhulu. »
ILos Angeles Times ithe ngamanye amaxesha ixesha layo leeyure ezimbini ezinesiqingatha livakala ngathi lingunaphakade. Ubukhulu becala, nangona kunjalo, uBerger ugcina ukoyikeka ngaphambili kunye neziko, azange kube njalo kunaxa uBäumer, ebanjwe nejoni laseFransi, ejongene nobuntu obungenakuphikiswa botshaba lwakhe.
Ngokumalunga nokuqaliswa komlingiswa kaDaniel Brühl, umxoxisi ohamba ngokuhambelanayo ukusayina i-armistice neFransi eyayingekho kwibali lokuqala, wabonisa ukuba “Isigqibo sokuquka eli lizwi ikakhulu libonisa uxolo senza abantu bangazithembi injongo yaloo filimu nakubuchule bababukeli bokuyiqonda. »
Kuphononongo olungenamdla kangako, iThe New York Times yaphawula ukuba "iBerger inezixhobo ezingaphezulu kuneMilestone ebenayo nemiceli mngeni yeminyaka yokuqala yesandi, kodwa ezo zibonelelo zenza ngandlela ithile olu hlaziyo lungathandekiyo: ukukhulisa isikali kunye nobuchule buboleka. ukubonisa.
Kungakhathaliseki ukuba, waphawula ukuba "i-movie ijolise ukukubetha ngenkohlakalo engapheliyo, kwaye kunzima ukuba ungakhathazeki ngaloo nto."
SOURCE: Uphonononga Iindaba
Ungalibazisi ukwabelana ngenqaku lethu kwiinethiwekhi zentlalo ukusinika ukomelela okuqinileyo. 🍿