INkosi yemisesane – Imisesane yaMandla
– Reviews Iindaba
Umbukeli uya kuba ngoluphi uhlobo oluza kubukela uthotho olutsha olufumaneka kwiPrime Video, INkosi yeRings-Imisesane yaMandla? Ngaba uya kuba ngumlandeli we-JRR Tolkien kunye neencwadi zakhe, imibhalo eyaziwa kakhulu phakathi kwe-1930 kunye ne-1940, i-milestones kwi-fantasy genre?
Okanye ngaba uya kuba ngumbukeli wemiboniso bhanyabhanya emithathu kaPeter Jackson kwaye, engonelisekanga zezi Hobbits zintathu zilandelayo, aphelelwe ngumonde wokubuyela kweli lizwe limangalisayo? Usenokuba ngumdlali kuthotho lwe imidlalo yevidiyo, enomdla wokubona ukuba yeyiphi na into eyenzekileyo eyenzelwe abalinganiswa abaziyo kwiimeko ezahlukeneyo. Inokuba ngumbukeli "ongenalwazi", othathe isigqibo sokuqalisa ifantasy okokuqala, okanye umntu othi, emva kokubandakanyeka kuMdlalo weZihlalo zobukhosi, acengelwe ukuba abe ngumlandeli.
I-Galadriel efanelekileyo kwaye enhle
Ngokuxhomekeke kudidi abakulo, ukuxatyiswa kolu nyango lutsha kuya kwahluka. Ngubani (kufuneka kuthiwe kwangoko) ejonge umsebenzi wokuqala, iinoveli kunye neefilim, ubalisa ibali elitsha ngokupheleleyo, amawaka eminyaka yehlabathi kunye nabalinganiswa ebesibazi, bethatha indlela yangoku, kwindlela imixholo eyahluke ngayo. baphathwe (abalinganiswa ababhinqileyo abomeleleyo nababalaseleyo kunye nabalinganiswa bemibala apho babeya kuba banyanzeleke ukuba babe lusu olumhlophe). Abadlali ababini bemiboniso u-JD Payne kunye noPatrick McKay bazobe kwiinqununu ezishiywe nguTolkien, amanqaku avela kwi-Lord of the Rings okanye ulwazi oluvela kwiiTales ezingagqitywanga. Isiteyitimenti sesihloko sokuvula kukuba umsebenzi usekelwe "kwiNkosi yeeNdandatho kunye neziHlomelo". Sinokuyichaza "njengebali lemvelaphi", ethembekileyo kakhulu kwiintsomi zikaTolkien.
Kwilizwe elikude elinomlingo sikhokelwa ukuba sidibane nabalinganiswa abatsha: iGaladriel encinci kakhulu, i-elf engenakunqandwa kwihlabathi lolonwabo oluqaqambileyo, esele isoyikiswa sisithunzi soBubi, oya kuthi emva koko abonakale eSauron. Loo mntu umdala uGaladriel akasoze adinwe ukuzingela, ngokuchasene nentando yokumkani wakhe ongakhathali, oya kunyanzeleka ukuba angamthobeli. Xa sasikhula, sadibana naye kwiimuvi ezineempawu zikaCate Blanchett.
Ecaleni kwakhe, kodwa engasoloko evumelana, i-elf Elrond, i-elf Elrond, ingaphantsi kwemvukelo, iyakwazi ukusebenza ngamazwi kunezixhobo (kwiifilimu zikaJackson, yayinguHugo Weaving); emva koko intombazana yasePelòpedi (izinyanya zamaHobbits), egama linguNori, ikhaliphile nokuba ingakhathali; ijoni elinomtsalane elinanye uArondir, ethandana nomntu okhaliphileyo, unyana onobutshaba; iNgxilimbela engaqondakaliyo neyoyikekayo, yawa ngokoqobo esibhakabhakeni; ingcibi yeshumi elinanye efakwe kuyo amakhonkco; UKumkani weDurin dwarves, umhlobo ka-Elrond. Kwaye kancinci kancinci abanye abaya koyisa indawo engakumbi ekuhambeni kweziganeko. Ngasemva, injini yazo zonke kodwa ihlala ingabonakali, iSauron, kuwo onke amandla akhe atshabalalisayo.
Isidingo sokwazisa uninzi lwabalinganiswa, ukwazisa ngeendawo kunye nokuphehlelela amayelenqe ahlukeneyo, kunokwenza ezi ziqendu zokuqala zibe zidinini kwaye zingamemi. Kodwa kucacile ukuba (sikwifilimu yeeyure ezisibhozo) lixesha lokuqala eliyimfuneko ukuqalisa kwinzaliseko yebali elilandelayo eligcweleyo. Njengoko besele sitshilo ekupheleni kwenqaku malunga neNdlu yeDraka, iphupha elikhuphisanayo neli xesha, siya kubona ukuba kwiiveki (hayi, akukho kubukela ngokugqithisileyo nakweli tyala) ababhali baya kuba nakho ukwenza umdla. uphuhliso, ukudala abalinganiswa abangalibalekiyo, ukusuka kwabaphambili ukuya kubalinganiswa abasingqongileyo, abakwaziyo ukusigcina sikrokra, isiqendu emva kwesiqendu. Nantso iqhinga, nantso isakhono.
Kufuneka kwakhona kuthiwe yimveliso engenakubekwa tyala ngokusesikweni, enomgangatho ofanele ukujongwa kwiscreen esikhulu. Emva kwayo yonke loo nto, akukho ndleko igcinwe (kukho intetho yebhajethi ye-460 yezigidi zeedola kwiziqendu ezisi-8, umntu uphinde azise inani, kunye namalungelo eencwadi kunye neendleko zokunyusa nangona kunjalo) kwaye ihlala ingumba otsala umdla, ngakumbi kwiimveliso ezifunayo. ezininzi iziphumo ezizodwa.
UBezos, othanda kakhulu umsebenzi kaTolkien, ngekhe wagqiba ekubeni angazimiseli, efumene amalungelo oBudlelwane beRingi, iTowers ezimbini, ukuBuyisa kukaKumkani, iHobbit kunye nezihlomelo kwiNkosi yeRings ( kodwa hayi iSilmarillion). Iziqendu ezibini zokuqala zilawulwa nguJuan Antonio Bayona, umlawuli weJurassic World ngo-2018 kunye neMizuzu eSixhenxe echukumisayo emva kobusuku bobusuku. Uyilo oluseti lugqamile, ngakumbi ulwakhiwo lwasemoyeni elven, izinxibo, izilo ezikhulu ezicebisayo, kunye nezihloko ezibalaseleyo zokuvula ezinomxholo wembali weHoward Shore. Uthotho lwengoma yesandi nguBear McCreary endaweni yoko.
Abathunywa abangendawo boBubi.
INkosi yeeNdandatho - Iindandatho zaMandla ziya kuba zeTolkienians ukubuya okungalindelekanga kwiindawo zabo zokubhala okanye i-cinematographic passion. Kwabanye, i-luxury "ibali lokulala", intsomi apho umntu anokuzicwilisa khona, phakathi kwabalinganiswa abaninzi kunye nezicwangciso ezininzi. Kuzo zombini, kuya kubakho ii-elves, abantu, ii-pelopods, iingxilimbela, ii-orcs, ii-dwarves, iidragons, izilo ezikhulu zazo zonke iintlobo, amaxesha atshintshanayo entshabalalo kunye neentlungu, amabali othando olunzima kunye nezibiyeli ukukhanya ngakumbi okanye okuthambileyo, njengoko kuza (kwizinto ezintle. musa ukuhlala ixesha elide") isoyikiso sikaSauron, okwaziyo ukuzondla ngeziphumo zobungendawo bakhe obudalayo, njengomoya odlisa ilangatye.
Kubonakala kucacile ukuba nangona umntu angathanda "ukuphila ngokuvisisana nendalo, ngokulandela imigaqo", kwiimeko ezithile oku akunakwenzeka, kuba "ububi abulali, bulinda". Kwaye njengesilumkiso kuthiwa "akukho mntu ushiya indlela, akukho mntu uhamba yedwa". Kodwa oko akuyonyani, ngamaqhawe kuphela akwenzayo, nangona emngciphekweni wokulwa yedwa kunye "nomngcipheko ongenakulinganiswa kunye neengxaki ezingenakubalwa", ukuboleka ibinzana kwenye i-saga edumileyo yefantasy.
Kwaye ke siya kubona (uhlalutyo lwentengiso luya kusixelela) ukuba ezintliziyweni zethu nakwixesha lethu lokukhulula kukho indawo yonke into, kwifantasy efana nale, yokuqonda okungenakulinganiswa, kunye ne-matrix ehloniphekileyo, yeembongo kunye neentlungu, okanye kwiNdlu. ye- Dragon, i-matrix yamva nje yoncwadi, ukuqonda okungagqibelelanga, kwakhona kulusizi kunye nobundlobongela obungakumbi, i-sanguine engakumbi. Njengoko ingoma edumileyo yatshoyo, asiyi kwazi de siphile.
SOURCE: Uphonononga Iindaba
Ungalibazisi ukwabelana ngenqaku lethu kwiinethiwekhi zentlalo ukusinika ukomelela okuqinileyo. 🤟