😍 2022-11-04 17:55:00 - Paris/France.
Mtundu watsopano kutsogolo. Yolembedwa koyambirira mu 1929 ndi Erich Maria Remarque, Palibe nkhani kutsogolo anali ndi filimu yosaiwalika mu 1930. Anapambana ziboliboli ziwiri za Oscar, zofunika kwambiri pamwambowo, Chithunzi Chabwino Kwambiri ndi Mtsogoleri Wabwino Kwambiri (Lewis Milestone). Less Remembered ndi kanema wa kanema wawayilesi wa 1979 wolembedwa ndi waku America Delbert Mann.
Pafupifupi zaka XNUMX kuchokera pamene inamalizidwa, mkulu wa ku Germany Edward Berger (mantha) ankaona kuti n’koyenera kuti atumize kusintha kwatsopano, komwe kanalankhulidwa m’chinenero choyambirira cha anthu amene amawatchula kuti ndi amene ankawakonda komanso kuonetsa koyambirira komwe kumagwirizana ndi kuyambikanso kwa mawu odana ndi nkhondo.
Pakatikati pa polojekitiyi panali malingaliro ochepa ofunika: panalibe ungwamba kapena ulemerero woti upulumutsidwe kunkhondo; zoopsa za Nkhondo Yaikulu zikhoza kuiwalika poganizira zochitika zoipitsitsa za Nkhondo Yadziko II, ndipo mu njira yake yankhanza ku zochitika zenizeni, kunali kofunika kwambiri kuti pakhale ubale wapamtima ndi anthu otchulidwa kwambiri, kuyambira Paul Bäume (wosewera wa ku Austria Felix Kammerer), wazaka 17 zakubadwa yemwe adalowa m'gulu lankhondo la Germany ndikumaliza. kutsogolo chakumadzulo.
"Pazosankha zathu zonse - kamera, nyimbo, kapangidwe kake, zovala, ma props kapena chilichonse - kunali kofunika (kuwonetsa) zomwe Paulo, kapena aliyense amene ali mu chimango, akumva panthawiyo. M'lingaliro limeneli, ndinganene kuti mwina ndi chithunzi chapafupi cha achinyamatawa, "Berger adauza Deadline.
Chiwerengero cha zisankhozi chakhala chikuwoneka kwa masiku angapo pa Netflix, pomwe filimuyi yakhala imodzi mwamitu yomwe imawonedwa kwambiri. akukhamukira. Kutulutsidwa komwe kunachulukitsa matamando omwe adalandira kale pa zikondwerero zapadziko lonse komanso m'dziko lake, zomwe zidamusankha kukhala woyimira m'deralo kuti apikisane ndi Oscar pafilimu yabwino kwambiri yapadziko lonse lapansi (gulu lomwelo lomwe a Chile Blanquita , komanso Argentina, 1985, Kutsekedwa kwa Belgian ndi Chigamulo cha South Korea Chochoka).
"All Quiet on the Front Lines ndi ntchito yayikulu komanso yayikulu, yochita mwachangu komanso molunjika komanso yokhala ndi zochitika zankhondo zomwe zida za digito zimalumikizana mwaluso ndi zomwe zikuchitika. Simalephera kuchita chilungamo chake, ngakhale kuti amadziwa momwe alili apamwamba, "anathirira ndemanga The Guardian, ndikuwonjezera kuti inali "filimu yamphamvu, yolankhula bwino komanso yodzikonda."
Politcha "buku lopatsa chidwi komanso lochititsa chidwi kwambiri" la bukuli, Chicago Sun-Times idawunikiranso: Monga mafilimu ambiri ankhondo abwino kwambiri, kuchokera ku Paths of Glory to Platoon, Saving Private Ryan ndi 1917, ndizovuta komanso nthawi zina zomvetsa chisoni, koma ndizodabwitsa kwambiri, kafukufuku wopangidwa mwaluso. chikumbutso chapanthaŵi yake chakuti achinyamata amene amamenya nkhondo ndi kupereka nsembe, kupha ndi kufa m’nkhondo ndi ongotengera maseŵera a chess aakulu, ovuta kwambiri ndiponso openga mopanda chifukwa.
Pang'ono pang'ono, tsamba la Indiewire lidatsimikiza kuti "pali zovuta zina za Teutonic pakupanga filimuyo, komanso pamutuwu. Monga wopukutidwa koma osati wonyezimira ngati Sam Mendes mu 1917, filimuyi ikuwonetsa kudzipereka kofanana ndi mbiri yakale, koma ikuwonetsa zochitika zake zankhondo m'njira yosavuta yolankhulidwa. »
Pankhani ya nkhondo, tsambalo likunena kuti “zachabechabe ndi zopusa zake zimakhalabe zokhazikika, ngakhale nkhope yake imasintha pakapita nthawi. Tsoka ilo, nkhani yokongola koma yomwe akuyembekeza kwa nthawi yayitali ya Edward Berger siwonjeza zambiri pazolembazo kupatula zowoneka bwino kwambiri. »
Los Angeles Times inanena kuti nthawi zina nthawi yake ya maola awiri ndi theka imakhala ngati yamuyaya. Komabe, ambiri, Berger amasunga zowopsa kutsogolo ndi pakati, osati kuposa momwe Bäumer, womangidwa ndi msirikali waku France, akukumana ndi umunthu wosatsutsika wa mdani wake.
Ponena za kukhazikitsidwa kwa khalidwe la Daniel Brühl, wokambirana naye yemwe amayenda mofanana kuti asaine mgwirizano wankhondo ndi France womwe sunali m'nkhani yoyambirira, adanena kuti. “Kusankha kuphatikizirapo mawu olimbikitsa mtendere ameneŵa kumapangitsa kuti anthu asamakhulupirire cholinga cha filimuyi ndiponso kuti omvera sangamvetse. »
Pakuwunika kopanda chidwi, nyuzipepala ya New York Times inanena kuti "Berger ali ndi zida zambiri kuposa momwe Milestone anali nazo ndi zovuta zaubwana wamawu, koma zabwinozo zimapangitsa kuti kukwezako kusakhale kochititsa chidwi kwambiri: kukulitsa kukula ndi luso kumangobwera. kuwonetsa.
Mosasamala kanthu, iye adanena kuti "filimuyo ikufuna kukugundani ndi nkhanza zosalekeza, ndipo n'zovuta kuti musavutike nazo."
SOURCE: Ndemanga za News
Osazengereza kugawana nawo nkhani yathu pamasamba ochezera kuti atilimbikitse. 🍿
